If you want to take a luxury cruise, there are two very different ways to do it.
You could book a suite in an exclusive area of a big cruise ship, sometimes called a “ship within a ship“, or you could book a smaller luxury cruise ship where everybody gets the luxury experience.
Both can be fantastic, but they’re actually quite different holidays.
And something you might not realise is that booking a suite on a mainstream cruise ship can sometimes cost MORE than booking a smaller luxury cruise ship!
I’ve tried both types of cruising, and I recently sat down with Em, our head of UK travel at The Cruise Globe, to discuss the differences.
So, which is better? And could you be missing out on something by always booking the same type of cruise?

What Is a Ship Within a Ship?
A ship within a ship is an exclusive area on a larger cruise ship, usually reserved for passengers staying in certain suites.
These areas often have their own restaurants, lounges, swimming pools and sun decks, which are separate from the facilities used by other passengers.
Some of the best-known examples include:
- MSC Yacht Club – An exclusive suite area with its own restaurant, lounge, pool deck and butler service.
- Norwegian Cruise Line’s The Haven – A private suite complex with dedicated facilities and services.
- Celebrity Cruises’ The Retreat – A luxury suite experience with access to exclusive dining and lounge areas.
The idea is that you get the benefits of a luxury cruise while still having access to everything that a much bigger ship offers.
I’ve stayed in MSC Yacht Club before, and I loved it!
There’s something very satisfying about walking through a secret door on the pool deck and leaving all the crowds behind.
But that doesn’t mean it’s exactly the same as taking a luxury cruise.
Have a closer look at MSC Yacht Club in the video below. It is an experience I will never forget!
What’s the Difference Between a Ship Within a Ship and a Luxury Cruise?
The biggest difference is what happens when you leave your exclusive area.
On a ship like MSC World Europa or Norwegian Encore, you might have thousands of other passengers onboard.
Even if you’re staying in the most expensive suite, you’re still sharing most of the ship with everybody else.
You can escape to your private restaurant, lounge and pool area whenever you want, but once you head out into the rest of the ship, you’ll find the same crowds as everybody else.
On a smaller luxury cruise ship, the entire ship is the luxury experience.
There’s no need to escape to a private area because the ship itself is generally quieter, with fewer passengers and more space per person.
You also tend to have more things included in your fare, so you’re not constantly thinking about what costs extra.
Of course, the downside is that luxury ships usually don’t offer the same enormous range of facilities as the biggest mainstream ships.
You’re unlikely to find water slides, go-kart tracks or huge Broadway-style productions.
So the important question is what you actually want from your cruise.

Are Smaller Luxury Cruise Ships Less Crowded?
Generally, yes, and this is something I don’t think people always appreciate.
Even when you’re staying in an exclusive suite area on a large ship, you’re still sharing some facilities with thousands of other passengers.
You might have priority embarkation, priority disembarkation or priority tender access, but you’re still part of a much bigger operation.
When I cruised with my Dad on the luxury yacht Emerald Azzurra, we experienced something that really demonstrated the difference.
We wanted to go ashore by tender, so we simply went to the tender area and asked for one.
They sent a tender over just for the two of us!
There was no waiting for a full boat of passengers or trying to work out which tender group we were in.
I remember thinking how different that was from the experience on a big mainstream ship.
Even if you have priority tender access on a ship carrying 4,000 passengers, you’re still likely to be sharing that tender with other people.
It’s these little differences that can make luxury cruising feel so relaxing.
You don’t necessarily notice them until you experience them yourself.
Have a look at the luxury cruise I took with Windstar.
Although I enjoyed it, their small ship experience didn’t suit me:
Do Ships Within Ships Have Better Entertainment?
If you love big cruise ship entertainment, the “ship within a ship” option probably has the advantage here.
You get access to the facilities of the entire ship, even though you’re staying in a private luxury area.
Depending on the cruise line and ship, that could mean:
- Large theatre productions and live entertainment
- Water slides and swimming pools
- Go-kart tracks or other unusual attractions
- Lots of different restaurants and bars
- Activities for children and teenagers
- Nightclubs, casinos and late-night entertainment
If I were taking my nieces on a cruise, for example, I can absolutely see the appeal of booking something like MSC Yacht Club.
We could spend the day enjoying all the exciting activities onboard and then return to the quieter, more luxurious area when we wanted to relax.
That’s something a smaller luxury ship simply wouldn’t be able to offer in the same way.
Em also made a good point about multigenerational family holidays.
If you’re travelling with grandparents, parents and children, a ship within a ship might provide the perfect balance.
The adults can enjoy the quieter luxury facilities, while the children still have all the fun activities available elsewhere onboard.
For some families, that really is the best of both worlds.

Are Luxury Cruise Ships More Expensive?
Not necessarily!
This is probably one of the biggest misconceptions about luxury cruising.
It’s easy to assume that a smaller luxury ship must be more expensive than a big mainstream cruise ship, but that isn’t always true.
Em explained that she’s booked customers into the most expensive suite areas on mainstream ships who have actually paid more than they would have for a luxury cruise on a similar itinerary.
Of course, this doesn’t mean luxury cruises are always cheaper.
Prices vary enormously depending on the ship, suite, destination and time of year.
If you’re already looking at an expensive suite in MSC Yacht Club, Norwegian’s The Haven or Celebrity’s The Retreat, it’s definitely worth comparing the price with a smaller luxury ship.
You might be surprised by what you can afford.
And remember to compare what’s included, not just the headline price.
Have a look at the cheapest Viking cruise I took my parents on. It was fantastic!
What’s Included on a Luxury Cruise?
This is another area where smaller luxury ships can have an advantage.
When you book an expensive suite on a mainstream cruise ship, you may receive additional benefits, but some things can still cost extra.
Depending on the cruise line and booking, you might still need to pay for certain restaurants, drinks, excursions or other services.
Luxury cruise lines often include considerably more in the fare. Some may include drinks, speciality restaurants, gratuities, Wi-Fi and even excursions.
Exactly what’s included varies by cruise line, so it’s important to check.
One of the things I love about luxury cruising is not having to think about paying for everything.
You can order something without worrying whether it’s included in your drinks package, or go to a restaurant without checking if there’s an additional charge.
I’ve been on luxury cruises where I’ve barely had to sign for anything!
It’s a very different experience from constantly checking prices or wondering whether something is included.
Although, do be careful when you return to a mainstream cruise ship. You don’t want to get too comfortable helping yourself to the minibar if it suddenly costs extra again!

Are Luxury Cruises More Formal?
This is something that really surprised me when I started trying luxury cruise lines.
I think a lot of people imagine luxury cruises being incredibly formal.
Perhaps everyone is wearing expensive clothes, sitting through long dinners and judging what everybody else is wearing.
In my experience, it’s often completely the opposite!
Some of the most relaxed cruises I’ve ever taken have been on luxury ships.
I think when people pay for a luxury experience, they don’t necessarily want to be told what to do or what to wear. They want the freedom to enjoy their holiday however they like.
Em agreed with this and explained that a big part of luxury is having choices.
You can choose when to eat, where to eat, and how you spend your time.
Some people might love dressing up for dinner every evening, while others would rather wear something much more casual.
Of course, dress codes vary by cruise line, and some luxury operators are more traditional than others.
But you shouldn’t assume that expensive automatically means formal.
I’ve actually experienced stricter dress codes on mainstream cruise lines like P&O Cruises, where I’ve been asked to leave certain lounges because I was wearing shorts after a particular time.
That hasn’t happened to me on the luxury cruises I’ve taken.

So if the thought of formal evenings is putting you off luxury cruising, it’s worth researching the individual cruise line before ruling it out.
Is the Food Better on a Luxury Cruise?
Food is one of the biggest parts of any cruise holiday, and both types of cruising have their advantages.
On a big ship with a “ship within a ship” concept, you’ll often have access to an exclusive restaurant.
You can also explore the many other restaurants around the ship.
This means you might have an enormous choice of dining venues, although some may cost extra.
On smaller luxury ships, you generally won’t have quite as many individual restaurants, but the dining experience can be very different.
Many luxury cruise lines include speciality dining in the cruise fare, and there can be a greater emphasis on flexible dining times and personal service.
Em explained that she particularly enjoys the food on luxury cruises because it feels less rushed.
There can be more flexibility around when you eat, whether you want a table for two and how much of the menu you’d like to try.
She’s even ordered multiple starters and main courses to share with the table!
Her favourite experience involved a cheese trolley rather than a normal cheese plate.
That sounds absolutely brilliant to me.

One Thing I Don’t Like About Luxury Cruise Dining
There is one thing that sometimes puts me off smaller luxury ships, though.
I like having a buffet available in the evening.
Sometimes I simply don’t want to sit down for a proper restaurant meal.
I might have been exploring all day, eaten too much at lunchtime or just fancy something simple.
When I cruised on Windstar’s Star Pride, the buffet area became a sit-down restaurant in the evening.
The food was lovely, but sometimes I just wanted to grab something quickly and casually.
That’s one area where the big mainstream ships often have an advantage.
They tend to have more casual dining options available throughout the day and evening.
Some smaller luxury ships have excellent casual restaurants too, so it really depends on the individual ship.
It’s definitely something I’d check before booking.

Do Luxury Cruise Ships Have Better Itineraries?
For me, this is one of the biggest advantages of smaller luxury cruise ships.
Because luxury ships are smaller, they can sometimes visit ports that larger ships simply can’t reach.
They may also offer more unusual itineraries, longer port stays and overnight visits.
I’ve taken a lot of Mediterranean cruises over the years, and I’ve visited places like Barcelona, Marseille and Genoa many times.
They’re fantastic destinations, but sometimes I want to go somewhere completely different.
Smaller ships can often offer that.
I booked my Windstar Star Pride cruise specifically because it sailed under Tower Bridge in London.
That’s something a large mainstream cruise ship simply couldn’t do.
For me, being able to sail right into the heart of London was worth choosing that ship.
Em also mentioned that smaller luxury ships often spend more time in port.
Instead of arriving in the morning and leaving in the afternoon, you might be able to spend the evening in port or even stay overnight. That gives you more opportunities to explore.
You might even decide to have dinner ashore and experience a destination after the day-trippers have gone home.
Of course, not every luxury cruise has unusual ports or longer stays, but it’s something I’d definitely consider when comparing itineraries.

Which Is Better for Families?
If you’re travelling with children or a large family group, I think a “ship within a ship” probably has the advantage.
You can have a luxurious suite and access to private facilities, but there are still plenty of activities for everyone elsewhere on the ship.
That’s particularly useful when different generations want different things from their holiday.
On the other hand, if you’re travelling as a couple or with friends and your main priorities are relaxation, dining and exploring destinations, a smaller luxury ship could be perfect.
It really depends on who you’re travelling with.
And that’s something I always think about when choosing my own cruises.

Should You Try a Luxury Cruise Instead of Booking Another Suite?
If you’re somebody who regularly books expensive suites on mainstream cruise ships, I’d definitely recommend looking at smaller luxury ships.
You don’t necessarily have to book one, but I think it’s worth seeing what’s available.
Em made an interesting point about cruise line loyalty.
It’s lovely to have a favourite cruise line, and there are obvious benefits to building up loyalty status.
If you only ever book with one cruise line, you might be missing out on experiences that would suit you even better. Sometimes it’s worth trying something completely different.
You might discover that you prefer the quieter atmosphere, included dining and unusual itineraries of a luxury ship.
Or you might realise that you actually love having thousands of people onboard and an enormous selection of entertainment.
Either way, at least you’ll know!
Have a look at the trip I took with my Dad onboard Emerald Azzurra here:
Which Should You Book: A Luxury Cruise or a Ship Within a Ship?
I don’t think there’s one correct answer, because both offer something different.
Here’s how I’d compare them.
| If you want… | I’d consider… |
| Lots of entertainment and activities | Ship within a ship |
| A quieter atmosphere throughout the ship | Smaller luxury ship |
| A private suite area with access to a huge ship | Ship within a ship |
| More services included throughout the ship | Smaller luxury ship |
| Water slides and activities for children | Ship within a ship |
| More unusual ports and itineraries | Smaller luxury ship |
| A multigenerational family holiday | Ship within a ship |
| A relaxing holiday with fewer passengers | Smaller luxury ship |
Of course, these are generalisations, and there are exceptions.
If you’re trying to decide between a luxury small ship or a “ship within a ship” concept, our team at The Cruise Globe can help compare the ships, prices and inclusions for you.
We’ve seen some fantastic luxury cruise offers recently, and it’s always worth comparing them with the prices of the top suites on mainstream ships.
My Verdict: Luxury Cruise or Ship Within a Ship?
For me, it depends entirely on where I’m going and who I’m travelling with.
I love big cruise ships.
I love the fact that you can walk around and constantly discover something new. I love the entertainment, the facilities and the enormous variety of things to do.
And I love the idea of escaping to a quiet, luxurious area when I’ve had enough of the crowds.
Have a look at The Haven, the ship-within-a-ship area on Norwegian Aqua in the video below. I loved my time onboard:
But there’s something very special about smaller luxury ships too.
They can be so relaxing that you don’t realise just how relaxed you’ve become until you’re onboard.
There’s less waiting, fewer crowds, and often far less to organise.
And perhaps most importantly for me, they can take you to places that the biggest ships simply can’t visit.
If I were cruising with family or friends who wanted lots of activities, I’d probably choose a ship within a ship. But if I wanted to relax and explore somewhere new, I’d be very tempted by a smaller luxury ship.
I wouldn’t say one is always better than the other.
But if you’ve always booked expensive suites on mainstream ships and never even looked at smaller luxury cruises, you might be surprised by what you’re missing.
Listen to everything Em had to say about her luxury cruising experiences in the video below:
Before You Go
Have a look at the ultra-luxury cruise line: Explora Journeys in the article below. Explora Journeys are actually owned by the parent company of MSC Cruises!
This Ultra-Luxury Cruise Was Almost Completely All-Inclusive (Explora Journeys)
Find out more about Regent Seven Seas Cruises in the article below. I haven’t sailed with them yet, but I would love to do so:
What Regent Cruises Are Really Like And Who They’re Actually For

Book a Cruise (I’ve Launched My Own Travel Agency)
I’ve spent the last 10 years creating cruise content online and over that time I’ve learnt that having a great travel agent makes a HUGE difference.
That’s why in 2026, I launched my own agency and built a team of real cruise experts who love cruising as much as I do.
We combine great prices with personal service. Just click the button below and we’ll find you the perfect cruise. No request is too big or too small, we’re here to help.